How a Short Strangle Blows Up
On 5 February 2018 the volatility index rose 115.6% in a single day. What died that day did not die from getting the direction wrong.
5 February 2018.
The VIX closed at 37.32, up from 17.31. Twenty points and one hundredth, in a day. 115.6%.
Two inverse volatility exchange-traded products effectively died that afternoon. XIV went into liquidation under its own fund documents. SVXY survived as a shell of itself. Between them they were short about 280,000 VIX futures as of the 2 February close — roughly $280 million of vega.
They did not die from getting the direction wrong. Whether the direction was right made no difference that day.
What is a short strangle?
Short strangle. Sell a call and a put at the same expiry. Put the strikes some distance out on either side of where the price is now.
If the price stays between them, you win. The premium you took in stays yours.
Most days, nothing happens. So most of the time, this trade wins.
That it usually wins is the trap in it.
Why is the maximum loss unlimited?
Everything you can make, you make on day one. The premium. That is the whole of it. No matter how well it goes, there is nothing above that line.
On the other side there is no line.
Because you sold a call. A price has no ceiling. Sell something with no ceiling and your loss has none either.
The put side is at least finite. Price cannot go below zero. That finite number is simply tens of times the premium you took.
Gains add. Losses multiply.
What actually kills the position — margin, not expiry
This is the part the textbooks tend to leave thin.
A short strangle does not die at expiry. It dies before it ever gets there.
Margin is not a fixed number. It is recalculated every day against the risk the position is carrying. When volatility jumps, the same number of contracts demands more cash.
The seller has to post it. If he cannot, the broker closes the position for him. A forced close does not ask about price.
A trade that would have won at expiry ends three days before it.
A short strangle is not killed by the loss. It is killed by the margin.
That sentence is the whole article. You can stare at the payoff diagram and never find this. The payoff diagram only draws the day it expires.
What does it mean to be short gamma?
Short gamma.
Gamma is the rate at which directional exposure changes. A short strangle is short gamma.
As the price runs toward the call strike, that call’s delta grows. A growing delta means the seller is, in effect, short more and more of the thing. Nobody did anything. The position grew by itself.
So the loss does not rise in a straight line. It accelerates.
To stop it you have to buy the option back. To buy it back you have to pay what it costs now. It already costs more.
The cost of getting out rises with the size of the move. Every short position in every market has this shape.
Can you lose money when the price doesn’t move?
Vega.
When implied volatility rises, the options themselves get more expensive. This is true with the underlying standing perfectly still.
The seller carries a mark-to-market loss.
Hold to expiry and that loss evaporates. At expiry there is no volatility left to price — only the outcome.
The problem is the interval. Margin is calculated against the mark. Whether you get to hold to expiry is decided inside that interval.
This is exactly what happened on 5 February 2018. The index fell a few percent. Volatility rose 115.6%. The side that died was the side that had sold volatility.
What do the survivors do differently?
They take in less premium.
Sell further out. Sell fewer. Own the far wing. If you sold a call, buy a further call above it. The moment you do, the loss has a ceiling.
That far call costs money. The premium you keep gets smaller. You make less on most days.
Making less is not a cost. It is the price of the insurance.
The ones who skip the premium usually show the better return. Right up until once.
Coming next
If a short strangle is decided before expiry, then the real risk measure is how fast and how far margin grows. The next piece looks at how margin is calculated and what a single short strangle actually ties up.
The seller eats time. Time arrives a little each day. The loss arrives all at once.
A body is built the same way. It grows a little each day and dies all at once.
There is no way to remove that asymmetry. There is only a way to manage it.
The marsh drowns the tree. A ridgepole is a ridgepole until the moment it is not.
Definitions
- Short Strangle
- Selling an out-of-the-money call and an out-of-the-money put at the same expiry. Maximum profit is capped at the premium received; maximum loss on the call side has no cap.
- Short Gamma
- A state in which the position's directional exposure grows against you as the underlying moves. A short strangle is short gamma, so losses accelerate rather than accumulate linearly.
- Vega
- The change in an option's price for a one-point move in implied volatility. A short strangle is short vega, so a volatility spike produces a loss with no movement in the underlying at all.
- Margin Expansion
- The increase in required margin as volatility and position risk rise. This, not the loss at expiry, is what actually closes a short-premium account.
Frequently asked
- What is a short strangle?
- Selling an out-of-the-money call and an out-of-the-money put with the same expiry. If the price stays between the two strikes, the premium collected is the profit. That premium, taken in on day one, is the most the position can ever make.
- Why is the maximum loss on a short strangle unlimited?
- Because of the call. There is no upper bound on a price, so there is no upper bound on the loss from selling a call against it. The put side is finite — price stops at zero — but that finite number is still usually many multiples of the premium received.
- Does a short strangle blow up at expiration?
- Usually well before it. Margin is recalculated against the risk the position carries, so a jump in volatility raises the requirement while the trade is still open. Fail to meet it and the broker closes the position for you. A trade that would have won at expiry ends days earlier.
- Can you lose money on a short strangle when the price doesn't move?
- Yes. If implied volatility rises, the options you sold get more expensive and you carry a mark-to-market loss with the underlying sitting still. Hold to expiry and that loss disappears. Margin, however, is calculated against the mark — and whether you can hold to expiry is decided in that interval.
References
- Cboe Global Markets (2018). After the Volpocalypse: Market Observation. — VIX 17.31 → 37.32 on 5 February 2018 (+20.01 points, +115.6%); inverse VIX products short roughly 280,000 VIX futures, about $280 million in vega.
- Natenberg, S. Option Volatility and Pricing: Advanced Trading Strategies and Techniques, 2nd ed. McGraw-Hill. — Definitions of gamma and vega, and the payoff asymmetry of short positions.
- Hull, J. C. Options, Futures, and Other Derivatives, 11th ed. Pearson. — Standard definitions of the greeks and the structure of margin calculation.
Published November 16, 2026