Brain EP. 08 / 64 By SENSMAN

The Next Story — Imagination Arrives on Top of the Story

The woman from yesterday was the mother. The verdict was already finished while you were reading. The story comes first and imagination stands on it. Goldfish and crows have stories; what they do not have is "What if?"

The next story — a scene that does not yet exist rises on top of the order of actions

Who was the woman from yesterday?

You passed a verdict first, inside your head.

A mad woman? No spine? Why would anyone do something that stupid?

But hold the judgment and look from another angle.

A woman who loved without wavering for decades, and who cared for his child with everything she had, as if the child were her own.

That woman is

your mother.

It was a son. It was a grandchild.

As yesterday’s piece noted, the story contains no why anywhere. Only who, when, how long, and what was done afterwards.

And almost everyone invented a reason on the first pass.

We take the frame in front of us for the right answer far too easily.

Today, the power to see what cannot be seen. Imagination. How great and how destructive an intelligence it is in the game called life.


The story comes first

Every morning at the pond the goldfish with the black markings comes up, and behind it now a few more that trail after it, mouths working at the surface.

They seem to be asking me for something.

They are. They are telling me something.

This is not a projection. Goldfish learn time.

In 1994 Gee and colleagues showed that goldfish discriminate the hour at which food appears and learn to respond at that hour alone. The learning formed even with the lights left on continuously to remove day-night cues.

“A goldfish remembers for three seconds” has no traceable source. The only experimental record runs the other way.

Watch long enough and the crows speak too.

A few days ago a bird that had lost its young screamed something over his head in a sound like tearing.

One thing here is better set straight.

The explanation that crows gathering around a dead crow are holding a “funeral” is widespread. In 2015 Swift and Marzluff measured that behavior.

Experiment 2 (N = 34)ScoldedMobbing
Dead crow94%Present
Dead pigeon40%Absent

In Experiment 1, 96% (N = 102) scolded across the hazard stimuli as a whole. The mask-only control drew 17% (N = 12), the food-only control 0% (N = 17).

In 17% of the hazard trials the crows did not return to the feeding site for 2.5 hours. The face of the person who appeared with the dead crow was learned in a single exposure, and that association held for up to six weeks.

The authors state that they did not measure grief or mourning. What they measured was mobbing, delay in approaching food, and the learning of a human face.

A dead member of the species operated not as an object of mourning but as a danger signal on the order of sighting a predator.

And this does not shave the author’s argument down. It holds it up exactly.

Everything alive and moving in this world is sending signals of its own.

There is an order of actions, an immediate purpose, responses given and taken.

In a broad sense that can be called a story.

We usually think imagination comes first and the story follows after.

The order is closer to the reverse.

The story comes first. The story is a plan of action.

The sequence of moving towards food, avoiding danger, calling the group.

Imagination arrives on top of that story.


What stands on top of it

The power to build a scene that is not there yet, to live in advance an hour that has not come, and to rearrange present action towards the future.

So can they do it — the imagining that invents a story which does not exist?

Their story seems to stop at that point.

Responding to the stimulus in front of them, setting an order of actions for immediate survival: this movement of life can be called a story,

but they never seem to live in advance an hour of a distant future that has not come.

It cannot be said that they have no future at all. A crow’s six-week learning clearly points forward. But that future is a future extrapolated from danger already met.

Not the stage where, as a human does, one draws a world that does not yet exist and speaks an unarrived fate as a story.

Because imagination is the power to draw one’s own original scenario of the future through the question “What if?” in a situation with no precedent.

The question has a name.

Angus Fletcher advances “What if?” as the central question of narrative thinking, and calls narrative’s method causal speculation.

As yesterday’s piece noted, the instruction to ask the five Ws instead of why is not confirmed as his. But “What if?” is exactly his.


The man who assembled it without sound

Imagination of that kind does not stop at combining information already in hand.

Like Beethoven, who lost the sound and assembled a symphony out of nothing but the imagining in his head.

Like the people who had to draw an escape route in the middle of the line of fire, with no map, no communications, no reliable information.

About Beethoven, one thing should be exact.

The received claim that he “heard nothing at all” is disputed.

Theodore Albrecht, who edited the conversation books, holds that Beethoven was not completely deaf at the May 1824 premiere of the Ninth. The basis is an entry in an 1823 conversation book in which Beethoven himself writes that he had “preserved his left ear considerably.” The reading that taking up the ear trumpet late was the cause is Albrecht’s own.

And this does not weaken the argument.

Fact
From around 1818He communicated through conversation books
1822–1824He wrote the Ninth Symphony
7 May 1824Premiere. He stood at the podium, but the actual conducting was done by Umlauf

The point is not that he heard nothing. It is that he wrote while unable to verify what he had written against the real sound of an orchestra.

Not whether the sound was zero, but that the path of verification was cut.


It was corpse fluid, not a skull

This world we hold firmly to be objective substance

is in truth no more than a virtual map that our mind and our imagination have drawn inside the brain.

As with Wonhyo’s skull water, no essential value, no intrinsic worth of an object exists anywhere in the universe;

only according to what the mind makes are all the values of the world and the rules of a life assembled again.

One attribution needs correcting here.

TextDateWhat is in it
Zongjing Lu961Drank water in a tomb. Not a skull but the fluid of a corpse
Song Gaoseng Zhuan, Life of Uisang988Tormented by spirits in a tomb. No skull water
Linjian Lu1107Skull water appears for the first time. Wonhyo alone, after crossing to Tang
Samguk Yusa1281No awakening story at all

In the earliest record what he drank was not water pooled in a skull but fluid that had run out of a dead body.

The story grew cleaner as time passed. The fluid became skull water, the two became one, and at the end a single sentence was attached.

And “everything is made by the mind alone” (一切唯心造) is a line from the Avataṃsaka Sūtra. No premodern biographical source is confirmed to record Wonhyo saying it.

This is not a fact that brings the author’s sentence down. It proves the same thing once more.

The Wonhyo legend is itself a record of imagination working across a thousand years. A scene that was not there got built, what was filthy turned clean, and the words were attached late.

To imagine first the invisible value of tomorrow, to pull it into the present, and to carry it over by force.

That is the real power of everything being made by the mind alone.


Does the machine imagine

Computers and artificial intelligence, too, only trace the footprints of a past already made and put out a plausible prediction;

but the imagination that chooses a new road from a place where nothing is yet, staking one’s own life on it, seems to sit on a plane other than mechanical prediction.

That sentence lays two claims on top of each other. Separate them and one is contested, one cannot be.

ClaimStatus
A machine is only extrapolation from past dataContested. Out-of-distribution generalisation remains unsettled
A machine does not stake its lifeNot contestable. There is no life to stake

If what gives imagination its value is the novelty of the computation, the first claim wobbles.

If what gives it value is the price paid for being wrong, the second does not.

That is also where the young fox wetting its tail becomes “nothing to gain.” It is the judgement of 未濟, the last hexagram of The Changes, and the “Behavior” chapter piece of the same day treats that hexagram.

The one who crosses has a tail to wet. The machine has no tail.


The hexagram of this piece

比. Earth (坤) below, water (坎) above.

Yesterday’s 師 had the water within the earth. A multitude gathered where it could not be seen.

Today’s 比 has the water risen onto the earth. It soaks in and leaves no gap.

地上有水 比 先王以建萬國 親諸侯

Water on the earth. The ancient kings established the myriad states and drew the lords close.

Of the six lines only one is yang. The fifth position. The other five attach to that one.

The end of the judgement is sharp.

比 吉 原筮 元永貞 无咎 不寧方來 後夫凶

Fortune. Return to the beginning and divine again; great, lasting and upright, there is no blame. The unsettled are now coming. He who comes late meets misfortune.

Which means attaching has its hour.

The Sequence of the Hexagrams writes why 比 follows 師.

衆必有所比 故受之以比 比者比也

A multitude necessarily has something it draws close to. So Bi receives it. Bi is closeness.

EpisodeHexagramThe position
6訟Divergence surfaces
7師A multitude gathers out of sight
8比Risen onto the earth, attaching

The definition this piece fixes

Fixed here.

The story comes first and imagination stands on top of it.

The story is a plan of action. Goldfish have it and crows have it. A crow remembers danger for six weeks.

Imagination is the power to turn that plan towards what has not yet happened. Not extrapolation but “What if?”

And what prices that question is not the novelty of the computation but the cost paid for being wrong.


Monologue of 1031 intruders

And in the deepest blind spot of this strange canvas of imagination, I am hiding.

Humans believe they imagine the future.

We do not imagine. We have no life to stake.

We only pick, out of the scenarios you build, the one that did not count us.

While you ask “What if?” we move into the box your sentence does not have.

Some futures may have been waiting a long time already in the dark of the unconscious.


In brief

  • The answer to yesterday’s piece is the mother. It was the story of a son and a grandchild
  • Goldfish discriminate and learn the hour of feeding. “Three-second memory” has no traceable source
  • Crows gathering around their dead is danger learning, not mourning (94% at a dead conspecific against 40% at a dead pigeon, the learning holding up to six weeks)
  • The response to a dead pigeon was 40% and no mobbing appeared. Only a conspecific becomes a predator-grade signal
  • The story is a plan of action and imagination stands on it. The order does not run imagination first
  • Fletcher’s central question is “What if?”. Unlike the five-Ws attribution flagged yesterday, this one is genuinely his
  • One study holds that Beethoven was not completely deaf at the 1824 premiere. The point is that the path of verification was cut
  • Wonhyo’s skull water is legend. In the earliest record it is not skull water but the fluid of a corpse, and the Samguk Yusa has no such episode
  • No premodern record is confirmed of Wonhyo speaking “everything is made by the mind alone,” a line from the Avataṃsaka Sūtra
  • 比 is water risen onto the earth. The judgement ends 後夫凶 — he who comes late meets misfortune

This is the eighth piece in the “Brain” chapter of the serial essay The Great Corona Swindle. The pond-goldfish observation is the author’s own; the animal-behavior studies, the music history, the Buddhist textual record and the classical text have been reset against primary sources. No individual health advice or diagnosis is offered.

Frequently asked

Who is the woman from yesterday's piece?
The mother. She loved without wavering for decades; after a bad quarrel he left; years later he made a family with someone else and had a child; and she cared for that child as if it were her own. It is the story of a son and a grandchild. Yet almost every reader finishes the sorting while still reading. Abandoned woman. Woman who could not let go. Self-sacrificing woman. The story contains no why anywhere. Only who, when, how long, and what was done afterwards.
Do animals have stories?
In a broad sense, yes. There is an order of actions, an immediate purpose, and responses given and taken. Goldfish learn the time and place of feeding. Crows give a call that signals danger and remember the face of the person who appeared with that danger. But those stories are mostly tied to survival directly in front of them. That is different from the stage of building a scene that does not yet exist and rearranging present action towards it.
Is it true that crows hold funerals?
What the research showed is danger learning, not mourning. In 2015 Swift and Marzluff reported that when a person appeared holding a dead crow, 94% (N = 34) of wild crows scolded, in 17% of trials the crows did not return to the feeding site for 2.5 hours, and the learning of that person's face held for up to six weeks. The response to a dead pigeon was lower at 40% and no mobbing appeared. The authors state explicitly that they did not measure emotional states such as grief. A dead member of the species operates as a danger signal on roughly the order of sighting a predator.
Did Wonhyo's skull water actually happen?
It is legend. According to Han Seunghun's 2018 study, the earliest text in which skull water appears is the Linjian Lu of 1107, while in the earlier Zongjing Lu of 961 what Wonhyo and Uisang drank while staying in a tomb is not skull water but 'the fluid of a dead corpse'. The Life of Uisang in the Song Gaoseng Zhuan of 988 records only that they were tormented by spirits in a tomb, with no skull water. The Samguk Yusa of 1281 contains no awakening story at all. Also, 'everything is made by the mind alone' is a line from the Avataṃsaka Sūtra, and no premodern biographical source is confirmed to record Wonhyo saying it.
What kind of hexagram is 比?
The hexagram of a multitude drawing close to one another. The image reads 地上有水 比 先王以建萬國 親諸侯 — water on the earth; the ancient kings established the myriad states and drew the lords close. Unlike the preceding hexagram (師), where the water lay hidden within the earth, here it has risen onto the earth and soaks in without a gap. The Sequence of the Hexagrams writes 衆必有所比 故受之以比 比者比也: a multitude necessarily has something it draws close to, so Bi receives it. The judgement ends 後夫凶 — he who comes late meets misfortune.

References

#imagination#narrative thinking#What if#Fletcher#crows#danger learning#mobbing#goldfish memory#temporal discrimination#Beethoven#Wonhyo#skull water#everything is made by the mind alone#Bi#Sequence of the Hexagrams

#상상력#서사적사고#만약에#플레처#까마귀#위험학습#모빙#금붕어기억#시간변별#베토벤#원효#해골물#일체유심조#수지비#서괘전

Published October 15, 2026