Brain EP. 02 / 64 By SENSMAN

The Threshold Came Down — There Is No Miracle, Only a Lower Activation Energy

Earthworms cross the path at night. No path appeared; the threshold dropped. That is all an enzyme does. It never creates a reaction that was not already possible.

The threshold came down — the activation energy barrier an enzyme lowers

He gets up before first light.

At some point the walk to the temple within five hundred metres hardened into habit.

At some later point he began carrying something in his hand. And watching the ground.

When the season turns and the nights stop being cold, something is moving down there. Earthworms.

On the way back from a fifteen-minute walk, what was one or two a few months ago is now about ten in his hand. The goldfish lose their minds at the sight of protein.

What makes them move under cover of dark.

They are not fleeing drowning

Correct the common account first. “The burrow floods when it rains and they come up to avoid drowning” is wrong.

Earthworms survive submersion for considerable periods. The real reason runs the other way.

An earthworm has no lungs and no gills. It breathes through its skin. Oxygen dissolves into the thin mucus layer on the body surface and diffuses into capillaries beneath.

That one fact sets every condition.

ConditionEffect on surface travel
The body surface driesNo oxygen uptake. It ends there
DaylightDiurnal predators’ eyes are working
Humidity risesDesiccation risk falls
NightBirds cannot see

A dry daytime surface is not a path. It is a place that kills on the crossing.

When night comes and rain falls, three things drop at once: light, predators, desiccation. Only then does the surface become a route far faster and cheaper than tunnelling.

No new path appeared. The threshold came down.

In 2008 Kenneth Catania identified one more such doorway. In the American South there is a bait-collecting tradition of driving a stake into the ground and rubbing it to bring worms up. The vibration, it turns out, resembles the signal of a mole digging, and the worms flee to the surface. People had been imitating a predator without knowing it.

The form goes; the matter stays

The worms in his hand become the body of a goldfish.

The amino acids, carbon and nitrogen that made a worm enter the muscle, fins and eyes of a fish. If a heron takes that fish, they become part of a body that flies.

One distinction has to be made here.

Across a trophic level
EnergyMuch of it dissipates as heat. It does not come back
Matter (elements)Does not dissipate. Only position and arrangement change

Raymond Lindeman quantified this in 1942. Energy flows one way; matter circles.

Form disappears. Matter does not. It becomes part of another body.

Before the enzyme comes the substrate

Across a pharmacist’s working life the word enzyme arrives countless times.

Some people talked about earthworm broth. Others laid out how fermentation works, or which food is good for you, as if disclosing a great secret.

So what is an enzyme.

One word has to come first: the substrate.

A substrate is what the enzyme holds and changes. The enzyme binds it briefly, lets the reaction pass, and leaves a product.

Which gives the decisive line.

An enzyme creates no new reaction. It only lowers the threshold standing in front of one already possible.

That threshold is called the activation energy.

Lock and key is half right

In 1894 Emil Fischer compared enzyme and substrate to a lock and a key. It is the picture that has survived longest in textbooks.

The comparison explains specificity — why a given enzyme handles a given substrate. It does not explain catalysis. A tight fit alone does not lower a barrier.

In 1946 Linus Pauling identified the point.

What an enzyme binds most tightly is not the substrate. It is the transition state of the reaction.

The transition state is the summit the reaction has to cross. An enzyme that binds and stabilises it lowers the height of that summit.

In 1958 Daniel Koshland added a layer. The enzyme’s own shape changes as it binds — induced fit. The lock adjusts to the key.

Below it, noise; across it, an event

The word threshold belongs to nerves too.

If a neuron’s membrane potential does not reach threshold, nothing happens. The moment it does, voltage-gated sodium channels open and an electrical wave spreads. Hodgkin and Huxley put the process into equations in 1952.

A small stimulus passes through. Cross the threshold and everything happens. All-or-none.

And here a distinction is required. Activation energy and membrane threshold are not the same thing.

Activation energyMembrane threshold
What it isA free-energy barrier a reaction must crossThe voltage at which channels open (about −55 mV)
Role of enzyme / stimulusLowers the barrierThe stimulus rises to meet it
UnitskJ/molmV

Not the same physical quantity. What is the same is the mathematical shape: nothing below, everything above. Which is why one word covers both.

And the threshold side is not fixed either. Under inflammation, nociceptor thresholds genuinely fall, and a stimulus that would not hurt becomes pain. Life adjusts thresholds from both directions.

Not ten million

The enzyme lowers that threshold. It changes the substrate and is not consumed. It lets the reaction through without becoming its product.

That is the definition of a catalyst, and an enzyme is the catalyst life uses.

Hydrogen peroxide left alone will eventually split into water and oxygen. Only far too slowly. A reaction too slow is, to a living thing, a reaction that does not exist.

Catalase takes that reaction on. It did not invent it. It lowered the threshold.

Here the figure in the manuscript has to be corrected. Ten million fold is an underestimate.

EnzymeUncatalysedWith enzymeFactor
Catalase—Tens of millions of events per molecule per second—
OMP decarboxylasehalf-life 78 million years18 millisecondsabout 1017

Measured by Anne Radzicka and Richard Wolfenden in 1995. Seventy-eight million years becomes eighteen milliseconds.

1017 is a number with no feel to it, so convert it. What happens in the space of one blink would, without the enzyme, take from the age of dinosaurs until now.

Put into sizes

The ratio is five million to one.

Actual×5,000,000
Catalase, about 10 nm across5 cm
Hydrogen peroxide molecule, about 0.3 nm1.5 mm
Human cell, 10 μm acrossA dome 50 m across

Inside a dome fifty metres wide sits a ball five centimetres across. That ball picks up grains 1.5 millimetres wide and splits them, tens of millions per second.

And it does not wear down.

Not every enzyme is a protein

One more correction. “What a cell does is done by proteins” is nearly right and not entirely.

RNA is a catalyst too. Such molecules are called ribozymes.

In 2000 Nissen, Steitz and colleagues solved the ribosome’s structure. At the place where proteins are made — the peptidyl transferase centre that joins amino acids — sat RNA, not protein.

The heart of the machine that builds proteins is not a protein.

Earthworm broth and enzyme supplements

Back to the counter.

A fibrinolytic enzyme really has been isolated from earthworms — lumbrokinase, reported by Mihara and colleagues in 1991. There is a fact of that family at the root of the earthworm-broth talk.

The problem is what comes next.

An enzyme is a protein. Swallowed, it meets stomach acid that unfolds its structure and pepsin that cuts it, then more proteases in the small intestine. It is absorbed as amino acids and short peptides.

Once the structure is gone, so is catalytic function. Eating an enzyme does not continue the work that enzyme was doing.

Digestive enzyme preparations designed and formulated to act inside the gut are another matter; their site of action is the lumen.

Saying this at a counter mostly did not land. “Enzymes are good for you” had already taken the seat.

The hexagram of this piece

乾. Six yang lines. The first figure in the Changes, and the figure of motion that does not rest.

The Image reads 「天行健 君子以自强不息」. Heaven moves without tiring; the noble one makes himself strong and never stops.

自强不息. It does not stop.

That is the definition of a catalyst: it lets the reaction through and is not consumed. So it does the same thing again. A single catalase molecule repeats the identical act tens of millions of times a second.

自强不息 holding at molecular scale.

The Brain thread opens at Gon (坤) and takes Geon (乾) second. The figure that receives and carries comes first; the figure that does not rest comes after. Thickening the ground first, then repetition.

The definition in this piece

Fixed here.

An enzyme does not make the impossible possible. It makes the possible-but-too-slow happen in time.

And what is too slow is, to a living thing, the same as what does not exist. So changing a rate is changing a world.

Monologue of 1031 intruders

We have thresholds too.

The receptor has to match, the conditions inside have to match, temperature and pH have to match. One thing off and it stops there.

We do not force a threshold. We wait for it to come down.

There are moments when yours does. Too little sleep. Mucosa gone dry. A cold, dry season when the cilia in the nose slow.

The same arithmetic as a worm waiting for night. We do not make roads. We count the conditions under which one opens.

You call it luck. Lucky not to have caught it, unlucky to have caught it.

On our side there is no entry called luck. There is the height of the threshold and there is our number.

There is no miracle either.

The threshold came down.

In short

  • Earthworms surface at night not to avoid drowning; skin breathing means a dry surface kills, so the crossing opens only when light, predators and desiccation fall together
  • Across trophic levels energy dissipates as heat while matter circulates (Lindeman 1942)
  • An enzyme invents no reaction; it lowers activation energy and changes only the rate, never the equilibrium
  • Lock and key (Fischer 1894) explains specificity but not catalysis
  • Pauling 1946: what an enzyme binds most tightly is the transition state, not the substrate
  • Koshland 1958: the enzyme’s own shape changes on binding — induced fit
  • Activation energy and membrane threshold are not the same quantity; what is shared is the shape, nothing below and everything above
  • The factor is not ten million; OMP decarboxylase turns 78 million years into 18 milliseconds, about 10^17
  • Not every enzyme is a protein; peptide bond formation in the ribosome is done by RNA
  • Eating an enzyme does not put it to work; the stomach unfolds it and it is absorbed as amino acids
  • The Image of 乾 is 自强不息 — not being consumed, and repeating, is the definition of a catalyst

This is the second piece in the “Brain” chapter of the serial essay The Great Corona Swindle. The pre-dawn walks and the pharmacy counter are the author’s own experience; mechanisms and figures have been reset against primary literature. No product’s efficacy is assessed here.

Frequently asked

Why do earthworms come onto paths on rainy nights?
Not to avoid drowning — worms survive submersion for considerable periods. The reason runs the other way. An earthworm breathes through its skin, and if the body surface dries it cannot take up oxygen. A dry daytime surface is a crossing that kills. At night, with rain raising humidity, desiccation risk falls and diurnal predators like birds lose their eyes on it at the same time. Travelling over the surface is far faster and cheaper than tunnelling. The route opens only in the window where the conditions align.
What exactly does an enzyme do?
It does not invent a reaction. It lowers the energy barrier standing in front of a reaction that is already possible — the activation energy. The enzyme binds the substrate briefly, lets the reaction pass over a lowered path, releases the product, and remains as it was. It does not shift the equilibrium position. It changes only the speed of arrival.
Is the lock-and-key account correct?
Incomplete. Fischer's 1894 comparison explains specificity but not catalysis; a tight fit alone does not lower a barrier. In 1946 Pauling identified the point: what an enzyme binds most tightly is not the substrate but the transition state of the reaction. Stabilising the transition state lowers the peak itself. In 1958 Koshland added induced fit — the enzyme's own shape changes as it binds.
Do enzyme supplements put those enzymes to work in the body?
Generally no. Enzymes are proteins, and proteins are unfolded by stomach acid, cut by pepsin and cut again by proteases in the small intestine, then absorbed as amino acids and short peptides. Once the three-dimensional structure is gone, so is catalytic function. Digestive enzyme preparations designed and formulated to act inside the gut are a different case, because their site of action is the lumen itself.

References

#activation energy#enzyme#substrate#catalyst#transition state#threshold#all-or-none#turnover number#ribozyme#earthworm

#활성화에너지#효소#기질#촉매#전이상태#역치#실무율#회전수#리보자임#지렁이

Published October 9, 2026