Simplifying the Problem — Fate Divides Not at the Right Answer but at Which Problem You Took Hold Of
夬 is the hexagram of decision, and yet its judgement writes 不利即戎 — it does not further to resort at once to arms. The earlier tradition says Alexander did not cut the knot. He pulled out the pin that held the yoke.
“Cross the river, or do not.”
When Caesar stood before the Rubicon, the deliberation was not long.
He crossed.
What was left was speed. Before the other side could form its line he drove through Italy at full tilt.
The sources write it a little differently. Suetonius left a scene of Caesar hesitating at the riverside. Though it is true the hesitation was not long. He crossed that night, taken to be between 10 and 11 January 49 BC.
And the words he left come in two versions too. The Latin is iacta alea est, the die is cast. But the Greek that Plutarch reports is ἀνερρίφθω κύβος, an imperative. “Let the die be cast.”
One is a declaration that there is no going back. The other is a man pushing himself.
The egg and the knot
While every kind of theory flew about on how to stand an egg upright, Columbus simply broke the bottom in.
This story too has to carry its citation.
| Record | Year | Who |
|---|---|---|
| Vasari, Lives of the Artists | 1550 | Brunelleschi |
| Benzoni, History of the New World | 1565 | Columbus |
Columbus died in 1506. Benzoni’s record comes 59 years after his death. And 15 years earlier, in Vasari’s book, almost the same story is set down as an episode of Brunelleschi, who designed the dome of the Florence cathedral.
The earlier record belongs to another man. Calling the Columbus version a legend is the accurate thing.
But the frame of the story does not change. Whoever did it, in a room arguing over the method of standing it, one man changed the condition of standing itself.
Alexander, before the tangled knot, drew his sword and cut it through.
Here too the sources are two. And on this side the correction makes the writing stronger.
Arrian and Plutarch name Aristobulus, who marched with Alexander, as their source and report something else.
He did not use a blade. He pulled out the pin that was holding the yoke fast to the pole. The pin came out, the yoke came away, and the knot no longer needed touching.
The version in which he cut it belongs to Curtius Rufus and Justin — that is, to the later writers.
| What he did to the knot | The problem he solved | |
|---|---|---|
| Sword version | cut it by force | the problem of undoing the knot |
| Pin version | pulled out the linchpin | the problem of getting the yoke off |
The core is the same, but the edge is different.
He did not solve the problem of undoing the knot well. He threw that problem away and solved a different one.
The world simply is
Is there anyone who came into the world with a principle of how a life must be lived already in his hand.
The standards planted by family and school, by religion and the age — a man lives believing them his own view of life.
There is no grand morality play to begin with.
Poetic justice, blessing the good and punishing the wicked, is a subtitle humans added.
The world simply is.
Myeongni (Korean fate-reading) reads the current of the energy, and the Changes (易) watch where the change is heading.
Strip the phenomena of life to the bone and it is the same.
A virus owns nothing and passes only information to the next host.
Life raises a body and leaves offspring behind.
To the gene that body is a survival machine on short loan.
The operating system the brain runs
In nature without mercy the way the brain survives is no different.
A brain barely 2% of body weight swallows some 20% of the body’s energy.
Try to make conscious every sensation pouring in and the biological robot locks up.
So most of the day is handed over to unconscious automatic response, what is called the zombie systems.
Not a metaphor. It is the term Koch and Crick gave it in 2001. A sensorimotor pathway that is fast, automatic, and in which consciousness takes no part.
The noise is let through and only the coordinates needed to stay alive are held.
Simplifying the problem.
The oldest operating system there is for surviving inside chaos.
“The Path of Feeling”, published the same day, takes the other side of that operating system. The place where consciousness explains, after the fact, the road the zombie systems already chose.
The one who weaves the web, the one caught in it
The spider draws thread out of itself and is a theorist who explains the world as a web.
Instead of running after prey it weaves the huge structure first and waits for something to be caught.
The plan grows majestic, the result stays outside the web.
The moment the ant walks into the web, the whole board disappears and even the right to define the problem is lost.
Inside the web the question narrows to one.
When can I get out.
While that question is held, the problem that actually has to be solved is pushed to the back. Chase every incident and there is no end to it.
So you have to find the problem that remains to the last.
September 1854, Broad Street
Cholera broke out in Soho, London.
The dominant theory of the day was miasma, bad air. The academy and the health authorities argued over the properties of the air. It was a huge web.
John Snow did not enter that argument.
He changed the question.
| Question | |
|---|---|
| Inside the web | What is the cause of cholera |
| Snow | Which pump’s water did the dead drink |
The second question could be answered. Because it could be counted on foot.
On 8 September 1854, the handle of the Broad Street pump was removed.
Here one common misunderstanding has to be cut off.
Taking off the handle is not what stopped the outbreak.
Snow set it down himself in the 1855 edition.
“the attacks had so far diminished before the use of the water was stopped, that it is impossible to decide whether the well still contained the cholera poison in an active state.”
That is Snow’s own sentence.
A large part of the residents having left the district worked on it too. The final deaths of this outbreak number 616.
His strongest evidence was not Broad Street either. It was the comparison of the supply districts of the two water companies. Houses taking the polluted water from downriver had a far higher death rate.
So his achievement is not that he stopped the outbreak.
It is that he changed the problem into a form in which one can act without knowing the cause.
Pasteur put forward the germ theory 7 years later (1861). The cholera bacillus was widely accepted only decades after that. The health authorities took the handle off but rejected his theory to the end, and concluded that this outbreak was the fault of miasma.
He did not beat the cause.
He only took the handle off.
The real player does not strain to do everything in the world well.
Out of tens of thousands of kinds of noise he defines what the problem to be solved right now is.
And pours every force he has into that one.
The hexagram of this piece
夬. Heaven (乾) below, the marsh (兌) above.
Above five yang lines one yin is left. The water pushed up has filled to above heaven and is on the point of bursting.
The Sequence of the Hexagrams writes why it puts this hexagram here.
益而不已必決 故受之以夬 夬者決也
Increase that does not stop must burst. Therefore 夬 receives it. 夬 is the break.
And then the judgement attaches a condition. And that condition is the whole of this piece.
夬 揚于王庭 孚號有厲 告自邑 不利即戎 利有攸往
It is displayed in the king’s court. One calls out in good faith, and there is danger. One informs one’s own town first. It does not further to resort at once to arms. It furthers to have somewhere to go.
The hexagram of cutting has written down do not draw the sword first.
That the tradition of Alexander pulling the pin is the earlier one, and that Snow counted pumps instead of fighting miasma, and the 不利即戎 of the judgement all stand in the same place.
Simplification is not a matter of forcing it through. It is the work of finding the point to cut.
| Piece | Hexagram | Where it stands |
|---|---|---|
| Part 6, 1 | 鼎 | put it in and pull out what was never there |
| Part 6, 2 | 夬 | cut, but do not draw the sword first |
The definition this piece fixes
Fixed here.
Simplifying the problem is not reducing the answers but changing the problem you solve.
Cutting the knot and pulling the pin look the same in their result, but they are different work. The first solves the same problem harder; the second throws the problem away.
So the standard of judgement is not “how shall this be solved” but “is this the right problem to solve.”
Walk into the web and the first thing to go is the right to ask that question.
Monologue of 1031 intruders
You are trying to solve the problem of wiping us out.
That problem does not get solved. We are 1031.
A few humans have beaten us. They did not wipe us out.
They cut off the water. They washed their hands. They changed the syringe.
They were the ones who took the problem off us and moved it over to their own side.
Not the ones who studied us, but the ones who counted their own movements.
Meanwhile the ones who built the great theories grew old inside the web.
In brief
- 夬 is the hexagram of the break, and its judgement holds 不利即戎 — do not resort at once to arms
- The earlier tradition says Alexander did not cut the knot. He pulled out the pin holding the yoke (Aristobulus → Arrian and Plutarch)
- The sword version — Curtius Rufus, Justin and others — is later
- The Egg of Columbus is first recorded by Benzoni in 1565, 59 years after his death. In Vasari’s book of 1550, 15 years earlier, it is set down as an episode of Brunelleschi
- Suetonius writes the scene of Caesar hesitating at the riverside. The Latin is indicative; Plutarch’s Greek is imperative
- The brain is about 2% of body weight and about 20% of resting energy. So most of it is left to the zombie systems (Koch & Crick 2001)
- John Snow did not fight miasma. He changed the question to “which pump’s water did they drink.”
- At the time the handle came off, 8 September 1854, the outbreak was already in decline. Snow wrote it himself — impossible even to decide whether the well still held the poison. 616 dead
- His strongest evidence was not Broad Street but the comparison of the two water companies
- The germ theory came 7 years later (1861). He changed the problem into a form in which one can act without knowing the cause
Fate divides, before any right answer, at which problem you took hold of.
For Caesar it was the Rubicon.
For Snow it was the pump handle.
For Alexander it was not the knot but the pin.
What is the single problem you have to solve now.
And is it really a problem you chose, or one handed to you inside someone else’s web.
This is the second piece in the “Igeo-Silgae-Junggul,” chapter of the serial essay The Great Corona Swindle. The ancient sources, the history of epidemiology, the neuroscience and the classical text have been checked against primary sources. No company or individual is referred to.
Frequently asked
- Did Alexander cut the Gordian knot with his sword?
- There are two versions in the ancient sources, and the sword is the later one. Arrian and Plutarch name Aristobulus, who marched with Alexander, as their source and report something else: that Alexander pulled out the pin fastening the yoke to the pole and drew the yoke away without using a blade. The sword version appears in Curtius Rufus, Justin and others. Some classical scholars take the pin version to be the more plausible. Either way the core is the same. He did not solve the problem of undoing the knot. He changed it into the problem of getting the yoke off, and solved that.
- Did the Egg of Columbus actually happen?
- It is closer to a legend. The earliest record is Girolamo Benzoni's <em>History of the New World</em> (1565), 59 years after Columbus died in 1506. Fifteen years before that, in 1550, Giorgio Vasari's <em>Lives of the Artists</em> carries almost the same story with a different man in it. In the competition to design the dome of the Florence cathedral, Brunelleschi stood an egg upright on marble and answered that if he showed the drawings, others would simply build the same thing. Because the earlier record belongs to someone else, the factual standing of the Columbus version is doubted.
- Did John Snow stop the cholera outbreak by taking off the pump handle?
- That is how it is told, but it is overstated. The handle came off on 8 September 1854, and Snow himself wrote that the attacks had so far diminished before the use of the water was stopped that it was impossible to decide whether the well still contained the cholera poison in an active state. A large part of the residents having fled the district worked on it too. The deaths in this outbreak number 616. His real achievement was not stopping the outbreak. It was that, instead of fighting the dominant miasma theory, he changed the question to 'which pump's water did the dead drink.' His strongest evidence was not Broad Street either, but the comparison of the supply districts of two water companies. Houses taking the polluted water from downriver had a far higher death rate.
- What are zombie systems?
- Fast sensorimotor pathways that run without consciousness. Koch and Crick gave them the name in 2001. The brain is about 2% of body weight and burns about 20% of resting energy. Processing every incoming sensation at the level of consciousness would not be sustainable, so most of it is left to these automatic pathways. The noise is let through and only the coordinates needed to stay alive are raised into consciousness. Simplifying the problem is not a metaphor but the operating method the brain actually uses.
- What kind of hexagram is 夬?
- The hexagram that cuts by decision. The Sequence of the Hexagrams writes 益而不已必決 故受之以夬 夬者決也 — increase that does not stop must burst, therefore 夬 receives it, and 夬 is the break. And then the judgement attaches a condition: 夬 揚于王庭 孚號有厲 告自邑 不利即戎 利有攸往. It is displayed in the king's court; one calls out in good faith and there is danger; one informs one's own town first; it does not further to resort at once to arms; it furthers to have somewhere to go. This is the place where the hexagram of cutting has written down that you do not draw the sword first.
References
- Arrian. Anabasis of Alexander, II.3 (on the Gordian knot; citing Aristobulus). — The tradition in which he pulled out the pin holding the yoke. Arrian and Plutarch both name Aristobulus as the source.
- Suetonius. Divus Iulius, 31–32 (hesitation at the river; 'iacta alea est'). — Suetonius writes Caesar hesitating at the riverside. The Latin is indicative; the Greek reported by Plutarch, ἀνερρίφθω κύβος, is imperative.
- Vasari, G. (1550). Le Vite de' più eccellenti pittori, scultori e architettori — Brunelleschi. — The earlier record, in which the standing of the egg belongs to Brunelleschi. Fifteen years ahead of Benzoni (1565).
- Snow, J. (1855). On the Mode of Communication of Cholera, 2nd ed. London: John Churchill. — The Broad Street case and the comparison of the two water companies. Snow's own statement that cases were already falling before the handle came off is here as well.
- Koch, C. & Crick, F. (2001). On the zombie within. Nature, 411(6840), 893. — The fast sensorimotor pathways that operate without consciousness are called zombie systems.
- Raichle, M. E. & Gusnard, D. A. (2002). Appraising the brain's energy budget. PNAS, 99(16), 10237–10239. — The brain is about 2% of body weight and about 20% of resting energy consumption.
- Book of Changes, hexagram 43 (夬): judgement, and the Sequence of the Hexagrams. — 夬 揚于王庭 孚號有厲 告自邑 不利即戎 利有攸往 / 益而不已必決 故受之以夬 夬者決也. The hexagram of cutting writes 不利即戎 — do not resort at once to arms.
Published October 19, 2026