Why the Seed Leaves Its Owner — Vavilov, Lysenko, and the Men Who Starved in Front of Food
He spent his life collecting things to eat, and starved in a prison cell. His researchers starved beside the sacks of rice they were guarding.
26 January 1943. A prison in Saratov.
A man starved to death.
The death certificate recorded lobar pneumonia. The prison medical record carries nutritional dystrophy and oedema alongside it.
He had spent his whole life collecting things to eat.
The replication unit is not the body
Replication unit.
A seed is not an individual.
A seed is a carrier that leaves the individual behind and goes.
One stalk of wheat drops its seed and dries where it stands. The fallen seed does not look back at the dry stalk. The stalk was transport, and transport is discarded on arrival.
The same thing a virus does to its host.
The capsid is not its own body. Put the genome down in the next cell and the shell comes off. Coming off is not failure. It is procedure.
To collect seeds is not to collect bodies.
It is to collect blueprints.
What he collected
Nikolai Ivanovich Vavilov. Born in Moscow on 25 November 1887.
He worked out that cultivated plants had not arisen just anywhere. Every crop has a point where its wild relatives crowd together at their most varied, and that point is where the crop came into human hands.
Centers of origin. Presented in 1927 at the Fifth International Congress of Genetics in Berlin.
He wrote down one more. Closely related species throw similar variations in a similar order. Law of homologous series in variation.
A variation that is in wheat is in barley too. Found in barley, go and look for it in wheat.
Mendeleev read the blank squares and predicted elements. Vavilov read the blanks and predicted varieties nobody had found yet.
Then he went around the world filling them in.
By the time the war came, 250,000 accessions were stacked up in the store at Leningrad.
A good many of them were things you could eat.
Spread out under 天山
In 2023 I went to Kazakhstan on an agricultural environment survey.
Behind Almaty stand the Tian Shan (天山), the mountains of heaven. I lay down flat on that ground, arms and legs out. I wanted that force in me.
大, the character for “big”, is the shape of a person with the arms and legs spread.
Lay one stroke on top of it and it becomes 天, heaven.
Heaven and a person are one stroke apart. That stroke sits above the one lying down.
The ground I lay on was the homeland of the apple.
In Kazakh, alma is apple. Almaty means the place full of apples.
Vavilov saw wild apple forest on the slopes of the Tian Shan. Nobody had planted it; it stood by itself. The fruit came in every size, colour and taste. He wrote that this was where the apple came from. Malus sieversii. The main ancestor of the apples the world now eats. Genes from other wild species were mixed in along the Silk Road — that is the finding of recent genome work.
The apples stacked up in a shop descend from that forest, and they carry a very small part of what that forest holds.
To improve a variety is to throw away most of the blueprint and keep a few lines.
The lines thrown away are on the mountain I lay down on.
Seeds lie down in the ground too.
The same posture.
Starving in front of food
September 1941. The German army closed around Leningrad. The siege held for 28 months and did not break.
People in the city starved to death. They tore the paste off the wallpaper and boiled leather.
In the store of Vavilov’s institute there was rice. There were beans. There were potatoes. There were groundnuts.
The staff stood watch inside that room in shifts.
To keep the rats off, and to keep an eye on each other.
Alexander Shchukin had the groundnuts. He was found dead at his desk. The packet of groundnuts was sitting where it had been.
Dmitri Ivanov died guarding several thousand packs of rice.
Lidiya Rodina held the oats.
Georgi Kreyer held the medicinal plants.
Heinz was holding not seeds but the book collection.
A book is a replication unit too.
More than thirty died at the institute that winter.
They could have eaten.
They had only to put out a hand.
A yangban would freeze to death before warming himself at a chaff fire
That is a proverb from Joseon, the Korean dynasty that ran from 1392 to 1897. A yangban, a man of the scholar-official class, would die of cold before he would sit at a fire of rice chaff — the fire of the poor.
Joseon had deaths of the same kind.
The storehouse ran empty and he did not hire out his hands. He did not go into trade. He starved and kept his dress and cap in order.
From the outside it is stupid.
From the inside the arithmetic is already done.
What a yangban was protecting was not his own body but the house. The individual ends in one generation; the house carries on. Drop the standing once and the place of the son and the grandson goes down with it.
A choice to put the body down and cross into the next generation.
The same structure as what the seed does to the stalk.
Shchukin not eating the groundnuts is the same. What he was protecting was not his own life but the blueprint inside that packet. Eat it, and one man lives a few days longer. Leave it, and one variety lives a few hundred years longer.
He did the sum.
What starved to death was the body, and what survived was the blueprint going to the next body.
How many years to wear the mourning dress
That arithmetic of Joseon has a dark twin.
- King Hyojong died. The court split over how many years his stepmother, the queen dowager Jaui, should wear mourning for him. Three years, or one.
The Rites Controversy of 1659. Fifteen years later, in 1674, it broke out again.
How many years a garment is worn sent men into exile. Song Siyeol was ordered to drink poison in 1689.
Nobody asked 「what is true」.
They asked only 「who is on the right side」.
Lysenko
Trofim Lysenko did not believe in the gene.
He said that if you handle a seed cold, that property passes to its offspring. The environment alters the trait, and the altered trait is inherited.
Genetics belonged to the bourgeoisie, he said, and his own work belonged to the people.
There was no proof. There were no controls either.
What was needed was not proof but a side.
In Lysenko’s manuscript Stalin corrected the phrase 「bourgeois science」 in his own hand. He wrote instead 「reactionary (idealist) science and progressive (materialist, Soviet) science」.
The moment science acquired sides.
On 6 August 1940 Vavilov was arrested in Ukraine while collecting seeds. On 9 July 1941 the Military Collegium of the USSR Supreme Court sentenced him to death, and on 23 June 1942 the sentence was commuted to twenty years. He died on 26 January 1943. The rehabilitation came on 20 August 1955.
From 31 July to 7 August 1948 the VASKhNIL session sat. Classical genetics was declared discredited. Rapoport alone refused to the end and was expelled from the party. Some 300 geneticists lost their positions.
Soviet genetics went under the ground.
The conclusion that Lysenko’s research had been conducted unreliably came officially in 1965.
It took 22 years.
明入地中
地火明夷 (36). The light is beneath the earth.
The Image writes it like this. 「明入地中 明夷 君子以蒞衆 用晦而明」 — light entering into the earth is Mingyi. By this the noble one, coming before the many, uses the dark to make light.
The Sequence of the Hexagrams takes the hexagram before it and writes this. 「進必有所傷 故受之以明夷 夷者傷也」 — advance and there is bound to be injury. Therefore Mingyi receives it. 夷 is injury.
The fifth line calls Jizi. 「箕子之明夷 利貞」. When the Shang fell, Jizi played the madman and lived.
There is a time when the bright thing goes down under the ground.
The seed is under the ground too.
The same place.
One thing only is different. Under the ground the seed is not rotting. It is counting time.
Who won
Lysenko survived. He took his decorations, held his post, and died old.
Vavilov starved to death in prison, and the position of his grave is not certain.
That is how the contest between the bodies ended.
That store in Leningrad is still there. It has a name on it.
The N. I. Vavilov All-Russian Institute of Plant Genetic Resources.
There is no institute with Lysenko’s name on it.
The replication unit puts the body down and goes. The fight the body wins and the fight the blueprint wins are scored on different sheets.
Shchukin died in front of a packet of groundnuts. The packet lived.
He did not lose.
He became a seed.
This piece belongs to the “Behavior” chapter of the serial essay The Great Corona Swindle. The 2023 experience in the Tian Shan in Kazakhstan is the author’s own; the years and figures have been checked again against primary sources. Vavilov’s cause of death is written with record and interpretation kept apart.
Frequently asked
- Why was Vavilov arrested?
- He was arrested on 6 August 1940, during an expedition in Ukraine. He had criticised in public Lysenko's denial of the gene, and Stalin backed Lysenko. A death sentence came in July 1941 and was commuted in 1942 to twenty years. The charges included espionage. He was rehabilitated in 1955.
- Did Vavilov die of starvation?
- Russian-language sources record the official cause as lobar pneumonia (крупозное воспаление лёгких), with nutritional dystrophy (дистрофия) and oedema entered alongside it in the prison record. Some English-language sources instead record decline of cardiac activity. Many authors take starvation to be the substantive cause, but no official record states it. Record and interpretation have to be kept apart.
- How many of the researchers in Leningrad starved to death?
- The totals diverge because the scope being counted differs. The institute's own material (ВИР) states that more than thirty staff died in that winter alone, and names five of those who held the collections — Shchukin (groundnuts), Ivanov (rice), Rodina (oats), Kreyer (medicinal plants), Heinz (the book collection). English-language popular accounts give nine among those standing watch; English Wikipedia gives at least 19. This piece follows the institute's own records.
- What was wrong with Lysenkoism?
- It pushed the claim that traits acquired from the environment pass to offspring, without controls, and it dealt with anyone presenting counter-evidence by political means rather than scientific ones. In Lysenko's manuscript Stalin struck out the phrase bourgeois science in his own hand and wrote instead reactionary (idealist) science and progressive (materialist, Soviet) science. That is the point where a question of true and false became a question of sides.
- What is the theory of centers of origin?
- The theory that cultivated plants do not arise anywhere at all, and that the region where the genetic diversity of a crop's wild relatives is highest is the place where that crop was domesticated. Vavilov presented it in 1927 at the Fifth International Congress of Genetics in Berlin. For the apple that place is the Tian Shan range, and the wild species Malus sieversii is the ancestor of the cultivated apple.
References
- Nikolai Vavilov — birth, arrest, sentence, death, rehabilitation — Born 25 November 1887 / arrested August 1940 / death sentence July 1941 / commuted to twenty years in 1942 / died 26 January 1943 / rehabilitated 1955. The death certificate and the prison medical record differ on the cause.
- Institute of Plant Industry (VIR) — size of the collection and losses during the siege — A siege of 28 months. The predecessor body was the Bureau of Applied Botany of 1894, and 1921 is the year Vavilov took it over and rebuilt it. The present name was conferred on 31 December 2014 (English-language sources give 2015).
- August 1948 Session of VASKhNIL — The session of 31 July to 7 August 1948. Classical genetics declared discredited. Rapoport expelled from the party. Some 300 geneticists subjected to administrative measures. Reassessment by commissions in 1965.
- ВИР — Институт и блокада Ленинграда (the institute's own record, PDF) — More than thirty staff dead in that winter. Those who held the collections are named — Shchukin (groundnuts), Ivanov (rice), Rodina (oats), Kreyer (medicinal plants), Heinz (the book collection).
- Россиянов, К. О. Сталин как редактор Лысенко (PDF) — The primary study of the editorial marks by which Stalin replaced the bourgeois-science opposition in Lysenko's manuscript with reactionary (idealist) and progressive (materialist, Soviet) science.
- Большая российская энциклопедия — ВИР — The predecessor Bureau of Applied Botany of 1894. The present name conferred on 31 December 2014.
- The Scientists Who Starved to Death Surrounded By Food — The names of Shchukin (groundnuts) and Ivanov (rice); nine of those who stood watch dead. This source spells the first name Stchukin.
Published November 15, 2026